Nirgilis All articles
Music

Ink-Stained and Intentional: The Zine Comeback Nobody's Hashtagging

Nirgilis

There's a Kinko's in Albuquerque that's been seeing a very specific kind of customer lately. Not someone printing a résumé or shipping labels. Someone with a manila folder stuffed with hand-drawn panels, collaged band photos, and typed rants about whatever's been living rent-free in their head for six months. They want 75 copies, saddle-stitched, maybe two colors if the budget allows. They want them done by Saturday because there's a record fair on Sunday.

The zine is not dead. It never really was. But right now, it's having a moment that feels less like nostalgia and more like a correction.

A Format That Refuses to Load

If you're unfamiliar, zines — short for fanzines — are self-published, small-run magazines. The format traces back to science fiction fan communities in the 1930s, exploded through punk culture in the '70s and '80s, and became the connective tissue of the riot grrrl movement in the early '90s. Photocopied, stapled, sometimes barely legible. Passed hand to hand at shows, dropped in record store bins, mailed to strangers through classified ads.

What's wild is that the same format is now being embraced by a generation that grew up with infinite, frictionless content at their fingertips — and is increasingly exhausted by exactly that.

"There's something clarifying about knowing a thing is finished," says Maya Okafor, a 26-year-old musician and zine maker based in Philadelphia who publishes a quarterly called Soft Interference. "When you print 100 copies, that's it. It's not getting optimized. It's not getting A/B tested. It exists, and then it's gone, and that feels almost luxurious now."

Her zine covers experimental music, local venue politics, and occasional fiction. She sells most copies at shows and through a small mailing list. She has no interest in putting it online.

The Algorithm Allergy

It's hard to talk about the zine revival without talking about what people are running from. Social media platforms have spent the better part of a decade training creators to produce content that performs — not content that means something. Engagement metrics, reach, follower counts, shadowbans, trending audio. The feedback loop is relentless, and for a lot of people who got into creative work because they loved making weird things, it's become genuinely demoralizing.

Zines exist entirely outside that system. There's no analytics dashboard for a stapled booklet. You can't A/B test a hand-stamped cover. The audience is whoever shows up, whoever finds it at a distro table, whoever a friend hands it to on a whim.

"I made my first zine because I wanted to write about music in a way that didn't have to chase clicks," says Darnell Cruz, who runs Frequency Ghost, a Chicago-based zine distro that carries over 80 independent publications. "I didn't want to write a hot take. I wanted to write something that would still feel true in five years. Print kind of forces that. You think harder before you commit ink to paper."

Cruz has watched his distro grow steadily since 2021. He ships nationally now, and runs a monthly in-person swap meet that draws a genuinely mixed crowd — teenagers next to fifty-somethings, punk kids next to jazz heads.

The Tactile Thing Is Real

Ask anyone deep in the zine world why they prefer physical print and you'll hear the word tactile a lot. It sounds like a buzzword until you actually hold a well-made zine — the specific weight of the paper, the way a risograph print smells faintly of something industrial, the tiny imperfections where the staple went in crooked. These aren't bugs. They're the point.

"A PDF doesn't have fingerprints," says Tomoko Reeves, a 31-year-old graphic designer in Portland who makes zines about food, grief, and Japanese American history. "My zines have fingerprints. Literally, sometimes. I think that's why people keep them."

She's not wrong about the keeping part. Zine collectors are a real and growing subculture, with dedicated fairs popping up in cities like Los Angeles, Austin, Brooklyn, and Detroit. The Brooklyn Zine Fest, one of the country's largest, has expanded its footprint every year since it resumed post-pandemic. Similar events in smaller cities are filling rooms that organizers weren't sure would fill.

People aren't just buying zines as novelties. They're archiving them, trading them, pressing them into the hands of people they care about.

Not Retro. Resistant.

It would be easy to frame all of this as nostalgia — millennials cosplaying the '90s underground, Gen Z aestheticizing analog. And sure, there's some of that. Photocopier grain looks cool. Risograph colors are beautiful. The whole thing photographs well for the exact platforms people claim to be rejecting, which is its own irony worth sitting with.

But the people making zines in 2024 aren't primarily motivated by aesthetics. They're motivated by ownership. By permanence on their own terms. By the desire to communicate with a specific, real audience rather than whoever the algorithm decides to surface them to today.

"I know exactly who reads my zine," says Okafor. "I know their names. Some of them I've never met in person, but we've written letters. That's not something Instagram gave me. That happened because someone held a physical thing and felt like reaching out."

There's something deeply weird and hopeful about that. In an era of parasocial everything, of follower counts mistaken for community, zine culture is producing actual relationships between actual people who found each other through actual objects.

Where to Find the Frequency

If you want in, the entry points are more accessible than you might think. Zine fairs are the easiest on-ramp — check Eventbrite or local record stores for listings in your city. Distros like Frequency Ghost, Microcosm Publishing out of Portland, and Quimby's in Chicago carry hundreds of titles and ship nationwide. If you want to make your own, the barrier is genuinely low: a word processor, a copy machine, and a stapler will get you there.

The weird, beautiful thing about zines is that they don't require permission. No platform approval, no follower threshold, no monetization strategy. You make the thing, you hand it to someone, and it exists in the world. That's it. That's the whole model.

In a media landscape built to make you feel like your voice only matters if it performs, there's something almost radical about that. Something that feels, oddly, like freedom.

Or at the very least, like a very good reason to go find a copy machine.

All Articles

Related Articles

Off the Feed: Why Musicians Are Ditching Public Platforms for Invite-Only Hideouts

Off the Feed: Why Musicians Are Ditching Public Platforms for Invite-Only Hideouts

Pressed by Fans, Played by Millions: The Unofficial Game Music Economy Nobody Saw Coming

Hiss, Warmth, and Wow: The Producers Ditching Digital for the Real Thing